No that's not true! Read the code please. The result is a simple
wighted sum without artificial unit.
> - the comments are just too rude ;)
> (though fun)
That's only a matter for the "smooth" anglosaxons. Different
cultures have different measures on this. I don't feel the need
to adjust myself to the american cultural obstructivity.
I esp. to the habit of don't saying clearly what one means if one
want's to criticize something.
> - the AGE_FACTOR calculation will overflow after the system has
> an uptime of just _3_ days
> - your code might be good for server loads, but for normal
> users it will kill what amounts to a random process ... this
> is horribly wrong for desktop systems
No that isn't true. I esp. the behaviour will be predictable.
> In short, I like some of your ideas, but I really fail to see why
> this version of the code would be any better than what we're having
> now. In fact, since there seem to be about 1000x more desktop boxes
> than Oracle boxes (probably even more), I'd say that the current
> algorithm in the kernel is better (since it's right for more systems).
You misunderstood me compleatly. I wasn't using an running oracle
db as a test case. I was using the INSTALLATION process.
Since you apparently don't know about oracle I will tell you:
It involves a lot of different applications. Infact TONS of:
Java, shell, compiler, linker, apache, perl and whatanot.
> Now if you can make something which preserves the heuristics which
> serve us so well on desktop boxes and add something that makes it
> also work on your Oracle servers, then I'd be interested.
I would like to state: The current heuristics DON'T serve us well
on desktop boxes...
> Alternatively, I also wouldn't mind a completely new algorithm, as
> long as it turns out to work well on desktop boxes too. But remember
I was testing on a NOTEBOOK.
> that we cannot tell this without first testing the thing on a few
> dozen (hundreds?) of machines with different workloads...
That's true for sure.
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to email@example.com
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/