Re: [OKS] Module removal

[Oliver Neukum]

Hi,

> To do this, have the `free_module' function use `smp_call_function' to
> ask every CPU "are you executing code for module XXX?".  The question is
> answered by a routine which walks the stack, checking the instruction
> pointer at each place on the stack to see whether it's inside the module
> of interest.
>
> Yes this is complex, but it's not that complex -- provided you can rely
> on stack walking to find the module.  (It wouldn't work if x86 used
> -fomit-frame-pointer, for example).

How do you find CPU's that are about to execute module code ?

IMHO you need to do this freeze trick before you check the module
usage count.

[..]
> Another possibility would be the RCU thing: execute the module's exit
> function, but keep the module's memory allocated until some safe
> scheduling point later, when you are sure that no CPU can possibly be
> running the module.

But what do you do if that CPU increases the module usage count?

	Regards
		Oliver