[PCI] building PCI IDs/drivers DB from Linux kernel sources

Thierry Laronde (thierry@cri74.org)
Mon, 30 Jul 2001 11:33:19 +0200


--WIyZ46R2i8wDzkSu
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline

[I'm sorry for crossposting, but since it could be of some interest for
Debian installation AND involves the linux sources...]

Please note that in the following, these are remarks _not_ bad criticism.
Maybe what is found by the script could be of some interest to people
coordinating the source writing.

GOAL
----

In order to allow a kind of light detection of hardware to be use during
installation, I wanted to build a database (for PCI: I start with the
easiest...) with the following format:

CLASS_ID VENDOR_ID DEVICE_ID driver_name

I have decided to write a script (you will find all the stuff attached)
parsing the Linux kernel sources in order to do that.

RULES
-----

The strategy adopted is to try to find rules that apply to a great number of
files, if not all, and to treat the least possible exceptions by hand.

For retrieving the information I found 2 main rules.

R1: mainly for the net drivers, since one person is at the origin (Donald
Becker), I scan the files in order to discover pci_tbl arrays of
pci_device_id, and retrieve info from here.
Since some files have the magic numbers hardcoded, and others use
constant names, the files are preprocessed.
When the preprocess fails (config.h is created, asm symlink too), I
suspect that the driver is not buildable for the ARCH

R2: for the others, since the devices ids are spread all around, I search
for PCI_DEVICE_ID_* strings, extract them from the sources, construct
PCI_VENDOR_ID and put the driver name, and finally try to preprocess the
database, against pci_ids.h and others macro definitions found in the
sources.

PROBLEMS
--------

Macro definitions:

I have found two macros not defined anywhere (sorry, this is for 2.4.6; I
haven't try for later):

PCI_DEVICE_ID_PHILIPS_SAA9730
PCI_DEVICE_ID_V3_SEMI_V370PDC

Driver names:

I try to match the filename processed (minus the suffix) against entries in
the Makefile, and even try a substring against the Makefile in order to
guess the correct driver name. When everything fails, the log file indicates
the problem, and I have built a "drivers_aliases" giving the correct name
for these files.

Class ids:

This is one of the main problem. For some drivers, the directory tree allows
an easy matching. For example for 'net', the drivers at the root are
ethernet, tokenring is in a subdirectory, etc...
For others, for example in 'char' one must almost try to put the match by
hand [this is not a surprise since in Unix like kernels char is a default].

Completeness:

At the moment, the DB (you will find it in the tarball attached) is an
almost 600 entries one. But I have only treated the "regular" (rules 1 or 2)
files and there remains 30% of exceptions.

SOLUTIONS ?
-----------

To be able to construct almost automagically the DB could be of some
interest, since pci_ids is not exhaustive, and definitions are spread all
around.
May I suggest some possible tracks?

* Use of macro definitions for magic numbers

Could the policy be to not hardcode the magic numbers but only to use
preprocessing and put PCI_DEVICE_* etc in place of the hexa values? This
could allow to use only rule 2.

* Define the driver name in the file

The driver name is not always easy to automatically guess. Could the policy
be that the driver name is defined in the source via a macro ?

* Define the class name in the file too

Trying to organize sources following the PCI classes distinction will not be
always a good idea. IMHO, the simple way would be to define too in the
drivers source a macro defining the class.

The class id is important for example to sort the DB. If one has to
construct an installer and has a limited place (general case for initrd),
one could want to extract only all the records for net devices from the DB,
or only SCSI controlers and so on...

Thank for reading,

Note: The DB constructed is _not_ garanty to be bullet proof. For example,
since this is only alpha tests, the class id are probably wrong for some
devices. Comments absolutely welcomed.

-- 
Thierry LARONDE, Centre de Ressources Informatiques, Archamps - France
http://www.cri74.org/

--WIyZ46R2i8wDzkSu Content-Type: application/x-gtar Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="dmodtools.tgz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64

H4sIAOwgZTsAA+w7+3vaxrL9Ff0VE5kWQy0efjQpPqSHGJzw1bF9ASenxzhYSIvRsZCIJGzT nPzvd2Yf0grbeZyb9n73u1W/xqCdnZ2d98wu7jx0kzD049p3f9hTr+/Wn+7t4d964+netv5X Pd/Vn+7s8Pf0ubFTb/z0Hez9cSRlzzJO7Ajgu2TmsShaPQr3ufH/o4+byn/wonf8xyjBl8q/ sb1d337K5b+39/Qv+f8Zz5r8nYXjuZOq7wXLu2+2Rr1R/4T8d3b26jua/HcR/qc6/oH6N6Pg E8//c/lvPKlNvKAWz4wN0IUPTTiImJ0wSGYMTg964LkxuJF3w6IYOnZiv7BjBtMonMMRnxCH y8hhsbGBmA7KsI1ChqFgGhzZURi4DP4mufh3J/Ke7lbD6Oq5Bn3AgiRigHB9Fkt00AumYTS3 E+/9Er/h2Ct7mTBrYN+EHoPNw8gOHFY2EA0uFsMiCq8iew74cRoxhlRNk1s7YvuwCpfg2AFE zPXiJPImiAa8BOzArYURoB140xWiwVdLpDXiG09YNI8hnPIvL4/P4CULWGT7cLqc+J6DW3dY gHywcWV6E8+YCxNCQxMOiYKBpAAOQ8SLGwmDfWAejkdAzMTvsL0FSMKmnRCVEYQLgiojFjtY gY9SSEGrnL/rW8125IIX8LVn4YJkhyhxQ7ee78OEwTJm06W/hRgQFt72hq9OzobQPv4N3rb7 /fbx8Ld9hE1mIY6yGyYwefOF7yFi3AQyO1khOxDB627/4BXOaL/oHfWGvxH9h73hcXcwgMOT PrThtN0f9g7Ojtp9OD3rn54MulWAAeMKhfM/wcwpFwfXhMT2/Fjs+TeUX4yU+S7M7BuGcnQY aqMLNjjhYvV5IRE7/TC44jtE2IyF++BNIQiTrVRJpHxiFrjA5kgEJCGfgkjkpFIMOBAghbgY bf828shcwiaK53HZE/N7gVPdh72fYciQt2hevu2wLRgsCQHmQfvwIowThIXXbahvNxoNC1Oi p1twNmhXSdWLPbeZM9etG2hUt7kZ1epPazt1qD9r7u02t+sgTQ66dwso4uTKpx5ovxgM++2D IXwSDB+uhaj4HldA5E7EUAVRabYecApbqRdBpXLDqOayGxQK9Dqx0CYajpeLRRiRCotRnIW2 SajR/B2SGJuDfYX8jhM+wQkjVIJEeqUqSJJQPhOfCbJI/wnUZVMv8Ij/MZA84gU6t9RWUir5 ejgHMcXhHHe3RFtAf4d2g0Q4UYhr4upoBTHtZtzpvukddMcVNP6EkKFExugnq7MtMR9fy83p BLgeke2v1pYHljjVapWzSSr6hHE8KMLgChExO14RP1yGyk1avMXtGNFMbSehuZuoxZxj6ErJ sXA2odKzuPxZ0Z+evTjqHXxW8BWjjZbf8nae/WQM+gedXr91ubh1L43+gH8xazd2VPO9iUwm TOPg9LRlXjkOWF2wTsB6i/oYRiYAjRwetV8OWqbVeX3SOTtCgM54/Gu3f9w9Go/B6lXp/6pp DF+fEvLiB/GhadWS+eIj2UIb/UHogO26gr2EtN15dXJASIftl2NE3DU/s3voHQ9x0fbRl+j9 Sz+c2H4TKHNIkL3MDozX7Ze9g6PecbdVWgukfng19XxWMt52Wga7c/yly1qGO6GXLcP2PYyj Mb5gU/Fm7sXiw9S7Ex9wp+KDRNWibR/69lVsvF96LGmZQUgbhEFiJ7ERTMYEFbfqsAHBhBwj /85dGMX0FGIcNTgQf8sDF0RL9EcNDWL7QYjtDAK3xBYciH8SKs71cIbm5GeTUAXTSRiwHEHf cj4h96lopAE7cplLsIvJGow0bTSVwEGPinFRAY7RoHF0HWk6QQ5jXoGmxM2CrycnB/acPTZT RgsGBKSijHA5XA5ehO7olqGcw2seusRGbjF+8FgXketYkSnbygugYSIeGypjchjJxMcIB28p pKFTwEHuO5R3E+lPQmTHIV98gV9ZFJCDw5W4lwt4zjC3FaaY2RG6TN3r0IoYwFdpOjMNfT+8 Jby0BDQNY3DaHpIZtErvqhXMKJZOcn7ejBcYnZoXFxUiVrhmdHLawOjH0ea5bf1et34eX1RG ZbWr0fnoolppVSvFkiF9cxcdrEa+dE/xMko5y2ncytwe+N61TGSaRjcjUCfsg/6lXtmq6N8/ ivWRgGMSICrj7cxzZAIQYyK6QPFh/uYFN+E1c6uGjO+tS+bMQjCLdRP+jQx1wWJQimvn70Y1 3GWtVrsqXRrC1McyO2uV/uPIjCQuY/uKtUzjjP42oagSvHPLucB/JvDirHfUGQ/b/ZfdIb1x YXBy1scAhB7xAoxC4dyKoN8VLwfi7bk1xcTsqHvcft1FGC2pRyJrKqHH3MSepAm9SuWNE2HO TQPajvpkOQUNSTrxHHXNXvrJhUHZu0BA0JOCTrUBBXSaVwzTbtRPTHechGSvJpNOUGBBJOnm +D6AT0RF0N/ZsWaLcRpGRXgNkbE62oO3HcKaMUNhJHPlpi3R5cxc7Q5dJ0/vEENUyHEY0VB2 kHuXUpZSQn4hUmyRHmJTEj6WMaBsFFKCR+tRdGSWjawWkpKYFdBdLnz0LlyZXzF/wVMYducl OPy+8F8UHpoijcXggTqeIRAZLePviSB0PP4KZ90U3rBoEsaogTyvfmhenLhUImgyt96ktLyR RY02KaPKWC9dFhRDJbs7bOKhK8OATeEChicnR4MmpC0KTAMMZWhmMW95xlsUT4IVC9r3WtWJ GfMBbiTyrmYJbDpfXppWH5r39UVqVex5vSLVqsyXp0dZKUilBC/59lFuTEsQuRIZJBNyi5iI yoQHy6ohDzO4wvFJWqZtUUUjqjia+EC9Zny2YDO53zxcBsL6DYNnbrBZNj4YBYcMo9hAORsF WbGCcJlnwXUQ3soy1tyXb4vcv5n7+waqSqRgqaybLzGExgvmYAWeZfXSeDwWPzFxTuE+FmE/ CtMwZ3ECHdWttHs9zUbPKvJWDSuyLpzceOEyxgjMc2itvsD0+QlfUOZf+oLyFeKUn6BXmmO6 xGWElhIihaIwxCUI8dzj2NKV2xOseRBYrIDJHyUoY/SRS8rh73HpCreM1gQKQFmx4PUjjMIE UiFqC1snJ4eBqihTSyyMqR5akY3GSfwEFFVYU3AMLLadAv5BE8bsEPNuRm5B6AFHXPw7BskE 9dWyU1YYBawJl1FA8PfBnz9/EPAKLQjzw+iGJ2VyjlFQiZYdx8s53yvKcd1d8614D7hxka1J hZGBvZg6fhHdMbS/G21WMX8ZVZ1ibdSoYXjHla8wc0RfCqVw8q+4Yo2Kmwcnx4e9l+NqpVyt /NjKJUKloixGQ6VkKsTW+Ei8nKCK1l5j4BEbP0dB/WJiavEe6nABP/wAH6B4FF6R8wTzvHEh shaJljwCpqRSMdGyBN+gvv8xI9Q8kcEWc68ccSlt5p9PHElwwMhpAaV/KMImJc1oKJgH48LU v8Iat8DFz1wlI4l5XULn1hgzy1RIXykiuca3ktH2BQyWE65JCvU9VhgFqYQtBfK1skuJ/kbC +wZUc6u0cTH0JCRInr6LXKYAQuRvyYvOF3bENEOUtjnhrTM319KR00FsgbwAf9O65Pl3gCrw /buSvt/UikvrBYmFFUnb+icvSvBFufj9qPH9ogRFucYl0u9N4RyegPU78ipdzIQL9HhA9GBk K2g827noaBuYUk+Pmi8SYRM0HBwDpOxLB/h75se4u4JWexY3N4vZV/gRGuVybu1//OMfTR5a loGNdSm5fS4S6lyOLqWdlNKaSkYuQvYETn3GU3vv7omJSCVN5pMnT+Q8fDv1dCecVcuaAx6q ojntBpBYD8S7KgxCMuiAMd6y0zBQ326LZwkbmHXwnIe6hQtqeqq+4LjXGb/pHndO+uP2wesu ZXH6Pm5sHzdLCMaTZTLWF7pmaDkEO7fvvPlyTj5fK3tVT4/yIySXUMwxY/Wo7ZoDizn5rujy 8s7cLe4Cww2t6ywWCBy39EhEY1vKhyEhiMu91+ojKpFOSq1lt48QZBC5qtfI5I2qbmL2VeAt JqwjuYZcCi8RoAOQdbAIYugeHczGLTRDa9q4VNqjiFa2U0yRbdWKH1Qp/bFGbrVa2fCmCP1A VS9syBJGpBfWxZrVGTWgRjYlyUgiKI2CEuB/l+SBpGlJSkzhhjKl7tzjFNqQAkZuHJyeQlH1 CFXfMIWQqz7Pspjt59RYrgVL30c91xWa3SWR7SRjvq5Q6TQeCUFSwqoUgIGJGu6bWOcsp9Mt oe+yb0QTpXI7wmvypf8T2SmyHxYf1zReVTTh4KiNabowEBBNZ+j0e2+6fVzmAekq4UrZfoDK aLN+d45ytK1p2zq8GH1obO2OPo7KUNl6fJBCbKno+MigEqCoR9ugEpwSF7vaAeVyoqOpM513 RiW3oznV3mpCBlX4XFv6ix8sVB59Xrd7x3DaP3nZb79+HIo/lW9Gj7FhPfjAS5YobZJ5O1ZW tzNi5DkUN8C6Sihk76MyyirLLDZM7kEL1qQM8cybJpToF3gnngYpRy9YWKOKD24GRHsqyD49 h6R53DJdRCsLIWGYwrwwqgokU30l2a/WMIigyV/n5q+XMAJZpCNTJwX3yBEDD5MzK6/Vkbyh gIkIH31fBtkLX7FYsuMmfReE8tWbFImst3NooFApy2WFXEDVPgYnvmC4WAs+KlirR84Mw/zv olNCrVgeeG5F7HnbkScl/AgwB8qjVlbwiqazPYlDn06pF3Yyiw2REQuJoc/gDsV8N6qa6Pd+ aIDm++6nfqkCvO3UlNAlQsHzr0WYipAQSrHRvuSxH/nNJjiiT4glL4/MMywxqVFHETlezdFX XRub4LhqU/sYw6+xgAv4GUmNt09rlD6iilVnsA9lww/AiqdpBqxA7XhuFckYHhrZN4xX6A9f tYofxOBHNaqdP2lhplfk4OkHwpF9EYc66dfYib3sW8ASHrD4+ZNp/IoOOktdG3Ftg0d+BmfD wbjfPeq2B10wRUljUjFDPlVbpqYO/WeP6YzKfmMuog/CHD9OQ6wSWmDyv1xcqfkKUQn0VpEI FIyzFo5XpcM6dSCVgq51KU2DW+sUl1NvxBJJuHRmaXa9nx51pYjS4yJ67Wp45Ks8HvlyPz0Y y2gPHdsfixxBHZalg8r7iGF1hKbRcMdcOZie5KHG0YEEfrixI4/S6zg9cyuK88bapUuaXPrx +7h0aen9/fRQzlSg+mgVR4VdyC6qwUsOs8gdExfSismKQ9QbADKPaOFUdD68VMheUt8Ft/Wo C7KsgY1qsgJnxpxrjCt8Pc5mSWh+MbJJsBpZ+0r5gWJ6onnfHeA85RFQmc16zmFLRPtIJcKh lC2KX5Kf5v1K9Mt6UBI5wlLhyRkaXvNWNGNUAyWqA5odHNFBeWgc8qPQS56dZw5AnRlYEbti d5ivVUZVx4SRAYoB1g1PWKQaypE7DGqxHPfBlAdipp54XiqWU3jki+cZnm08bdoGIZ3FCKfJ D/N5kZWWl2vlvskrSB6zMvVIz3xl34QvjATfOmDdXvIZPOwFE4Ed82w1xZSC+pRKUWqpMhZZ 1hkyjmpqojX0cru8f4Sg7iPxzmjAN6m009DmHms9POKQO2mqPNPUwNLzJgqhTUjDUQYxyI2r +JeN/4rmz3zVg0cQcowaAPe+spc4WVNUHs56Azg+GQL1tVZbMA9v+NUy1EBxOalKjRA6DHAR EQY54mV2bYnuG9FELhqsRDE6MVGGOnQLBEvYKd0Ao4JU9s6wXnGZzxJ+pwn1J7AEAsxOoMm/ y+NgUq8JS/h0OiUOQm4baFIGWWa8nsLNbxSD1d/qxL7GVN5OIFVxyLJ9edrML0JoykH749pN vXeGbF3J3myQHr7KghzoOMXj6h7R3SpuB3TwvIzQC6vjdK4hXKepKUVpcUFFvvSYVuxCdQq/ x7KnhgXsu1rW/KGalI4e6ETv0WkiGtfERG1a2nJKZ0pMa2uqppzAkyHIlO1vllgUX4ojlAy3 yPEBxTwvA6+7Wmb9rr5d3xH5K6BbtzGVFvPSBracBeA9a9QTJ6w62uxGoy7rgwINjyMUvz5O d3BxHDYAPz97VqeTIRY40YpnwL/QPLZw7Pycp/VtiTNmGDL9R0dXmGlhnvfY+K2b0G2B/PCz dLhyn05OD2bkoDGk9q9wFSeec/3Ytn7Gbf3Cwb3tUAdiCieOuEwfSbmGI4yxxs7Pu9mwo02L 3SAvq101NGeuZ9ci2/Vya+5mmAXEDS69BpGix4zycXEDdZLu7vLc2065h8VsfiDFiuFAYyGu UZs6+u52teVrXuTa2aCbo60WX08XD66uhn9+hvJ/hAyCSMJrFlDvPw/TyMEsfW/xCRy3dn6F Z+ujNX/uPAKxsCO6dZhXz3R1Su/zWpFOjCk+PyLXexLdUfN4MVnI+v1pO8gUAsYxmSFm9ZbA KdvRJLz8GZl8qV/qku1k9T3tJ+ebVJv9RtmUs6kKkw5Nvsk6uMq5TPWsL6WLHkmbokO7jpU2 tlMaVKMlc4jW89OsWyzvXTVFAJQHBnN+Bk/HpxP9niiFB1H2bS5EjxuBvemK76qgL6K+O2GA icySpXTIVrwiSu8TPkLrya8PYaev1EOX3X1QklJy1m6L9jpS1sInPyztda6uHYtqtOlX9fJy 387kvi747YxF6clKrVo5f9e2/jm+yBE7xigqesA8ksqv6roXbwq/y85Zci1DwiO7+oSnAWuI G+NcR/Eq7SSPFHF6YzHP88dFkR2w5EVAcWaWmVmO9ZlCa6a2Zlf8zmKOw/RG4/E6eeldRk5l JgMJrBOZGs4nDGYdPeVDlGIKnTfvkcBfSJ2Uykn/yBYWHGJFRHkav9cs7iaI7oSbu8nMbxjL 69I25n52RH5Pz635VUN5jRB4cQ6bXpVVOUodVVmtpZ2QUHFniOIsX+bkSrNzZ3bxpdWZ0mfV bMkdaZACKm2ukA5Sy0XMjtGn4J9l4L0Hy1Mv5bFztbJ2MqIQadcecxBkBxveNEAaYNRo/tDc YMjuaU2tRiclzRKYo0Dsi/RcNDpINqdZGo1pMJ1X4Sd1GU3j/em9W60KiPPVWSCnTsHqrbfF cINSFEXZIuFEZG/XumiiG8UNaA1QEp1VDaqaNzg/tTMOxdhc8aCUMKIfWQT0iW5FCS0US2i7 7QrnzG/CJlRBrsOK24u5i3ubt/JeGFUQsluEvk93el8mzFFD+Ce5zwd15nm6BO2tI+7DCXLp YrZmvLnqetgeDtZLbr06PV67I63uceeKeK3iXr/NrcFhMvAp0O0c6LYO2lHOTAchD2fmJKRu gOtQ/F64mVNbebc6PVjTmhKLyYOg4nwkf41b3qMU2QFdsBZ3nhdoanaQlBU+lYw8jDd3vVte c0hn0kvevzugsyxetvu+ONgyRA+mYPxv/4Tvf/Rov//8bUC3Zv6AnwB/1e+/d+n3n7sNHP7r 979/wpPJ/+jkoH1Evqj7rVXg63//v7u71/hL/n/G86D8xQnGN1ODL//9P77e20H57z1t7P0l /z/j+ZT8/5u9a1tu3Nayz/ZX6GlqJjUdEwDByyMtyW6dSJYi2Y77vLAoiu5WxbZ8JCfHna8f XHgBKWxuKDnVqZpqV+KWtdZeGwCBjSvJ9obdn/chV00CGdeB6y/CfXX9A4+JekK9wKPf7/// Fj8XWf66vTiXY3v1+znfZvLDy+uFvBEq/zE/P/wqtxp2L+LjhVztvPiyPWRyY/7lcftZfbkp yn8+CLv6o7b+uzP4/af3p6/9d3b+/7QPrP37PKzav/go4j8l4r/v7f9b/GRvzyLO74uDnIo9 /5ifNX+cK2y3L6jnFRIRH1P5+bxa+Je/NputwORf58aCv/j3c6G+V38qaC+rlc/Ft+rTudq5 2b5SOfMXX4pP+qtqR6ncWjo3Nkku/tizgFBPgH/s9mIOphbhL4rn34j3K7kolco/SzA/+DQi 5T8yh/rTuRY8bA/y/7Q0FR8f1yUkan928bjeFL/LJIs/BPJ3X67/+E9f+28O2vw1H/3tnxOf 1v1/yELR/5MwFMOA7+3/G/xUa5TtlXk2nM/Erzji59WRNYhwprZayble3zwH9EZXD+n9fD6a z0FFg6I1Y0xzmlyu0utkNktAzYYyUJqRk+bsoV9w9qDVgn61ZDpJCWcMEKvgM5FdTcPEuJgW 94hJWIppGiY2/zicyF3tdMZpr2ybKHKu+f366Yxwn6QeqFsRVOZ9F72AInqKIPXEBxc9humx So+56VFMj1Z61EUPK7+gKr/Arfz8ENMLK73QRY9j6eNV+vD6cjue36TJcHwzGabD+WIxXoLK x1TdGtEyNQ2vJpfLsZMLxRwMXMJcMhtxERRDHxKu8MHZEZCuhqsJKp9OlvOba9FHwyXfIsmd P+89xEPVYjGdyJguvhZDPG8iotwwuYF82Nlul6Fju7i6dPQimAOdH/nUQHcv1+Ob8XIydPBS MhsvyPW+vI38CNBVWKnEuHeGK8U9SnGthCcp7ElSWCcpKHChnhSFdYqCx36hIfGg9iAhGR88 38M0AihTElIxJsI0KAE1BCQ0xG9Mg1Go3UlIaIjfmMZkubxbpX5AQKmGUW77e+8BWhkbK4rq UlMXaUqNFTR0Mximro/ozsajSSL+iRiLoBFcmzTQJ7BO0IViS5ukdbHyrU1CBlYkk6NiCCGn yOLJDavkEiTOipC2GD/QVJTX/TUka3J0xOMuqqmIk7fKCGzZXZ5bmhfU8/8BSSpQNlM8XCzH ye3kfpyOZ3fE+wka3HZpTv3XcPlJTJKn6XClVhEgZZNUtgekaEfzmSix0eyBkZiMAOE2yWnu NR5+FF9ErI4KZwB+puWQsi3pgd8vF/ilHFKc4+EyAZWWSSmChJLxUFzGJB3fkxhsmi2OuCCR ovaqTubiCyhxCiyTh0TQ8c1qfjP5OR3e8iiCgn6bJGdZEdYbVSbjFWEhpqtJUhe/xKYJVMXb JKGrub26q5X8X4dwu2jDONOx/uzs4ofBcyaXJHcDMvjhwskFicHxgsGoOyvjD/EjHM5Kh6qf /I/6PNPeVLZqL2fOLsCxncEwshUC2Rqfki13n2faZztzY6fcrebTOVjVKry6WMjK0FWyTKZT MYNb3MSisq+g1Zwjnkx/hmhPlqFH1pCiRlXPv8EC8/XdZDodz+a36Sx5mCyT0WQOyFqYsiDQ 0P9xkf6D8ohDw4oaV2rYIsdkdCv/D0PqQVfKpDjNoORjV6ep73vgkpvBEJcnJDHSjWq+vNEF CjIGo24qIaFIUGyswMw3DFPXqQSk1UhMh1xSXfK0OtK9dq3wtJc8rY50bI0VvB7R4jSlgvTo phWe5nFZ4krZsX5wNMXcqB+EMMf6wdH0cqN+CF23K0h9n10/YGmuWGVZZG5pLq2QdFesStut XtMIDhYNQ47qfeJ25SQ/SdCSKFla2bEcYjStcZlWx1rmo+1ZMtQGQOYYKDgqyb26oVHuVm0n w4/QokFDUBn3nTIu6NCuR0NQepGb3oh4FFqNMimqI6PI+KAxYP1FqSm6c8TKcfExWY1TzkNo lcRglHtRg0G/5nQ1STkT8RhcKTIY8mojaTTYaRDgkoIkVZF6Ob0bjm9u06tfGIWuuUlRMxts UWSWjK7HaTK7TFarZDSH9gK6tCqoosOOrmF6mUAzbhtV+0ACtzb8OF9O/jmHFtJbnKZTQGdo s+R2OX9Ir+GZlME4O1ExTa4XuKpknbmVtbahTsq0VvY4VvNMG2Om3s/Syo6l4Tul2TfTjMSz m+FSNS9OPKjGmRRRG5AJScmOwBjREAZIeTbMBMqySRm4ZTUC140bwgAZDlZMcPW9IQyQZlkz sVRRPkCGvxUzwFIVeANk/61igr1HQxBVAtlxabjQsrrBUCs3rnrQ2qzBkEtrjukDT5c0BKG2 cRVLx7cf5YtDblHVmqkm6iEWwSrDGEtvLNObu4phFyfWF8exPsdQh94QhNoaERsPU3nUA5Iq YTV+ybELI8h3i1FIowAaW5qUqvPzvACrjrUVuOhpUhph9xSDq54mxRBG9lJvxnP1mJz0ZkZ5 kNynyR282GMny2aFbiG0Tf/5cIKfiqz9YNFqLEbHU7ldfpvK5Q7R//2ySjk8GoENRKd5iQ6u O+a3cH3q8M7OlD7ahsa31+NkmV4nAdzDmByhKn5jPbNpAQalFknqMkx3rs8rzOWuNTTibnHO 9DYFFuYbGwZ2ji1OpYuUrmkDBakWp9JFBgXLBQnEPO0KkKxgtz2a5YLRXjENnzltuS0X/s93 4IyiRN22tpaLqDdZkZEq5DoIMtR/S6gUQZq+YM5gkVkpMkRF5sNbqP8r0VIKCXnLxQLqrSRU iiSoCLTHIaFS5LJfZMVSuSM2vJ9cjleAWosj+448wyZmq+tJeRIN0qwJTsdmxfReDHig7Jao zLFm9UtNrlOyEqH2HZSrGYP/BqGUc2/wX3Jc+/iY/4+DT4r6pLBPeuQzcvNJFinFvGoO4FeD fya3qN8eryf7/Cm9gqZ/CpOVw0cXFEQ9/5QOH0aMUqi7Nilq3MGwursYDyfJdPKQrh7Sh8k8 nczBimyhqiUyLN23xoHn6T2Y9i5Nj5uQ9HeMoM67S1Pa5DRtqKPt0pQ2thxiGgnE9zk0SrIw deqRHlPYiS+mn26gbcCGoEsaS/FyMpKjQH/0S3I/TkegbJd35lRH2lZwors8rY6Uxf0kSSM6 DGL4eLVJqach4i8HYRawfllFqEUZ1gFrmxBJqyI0oi4prepRj2xFkcdQPR8ZSd3Pl7fjh/R6 dBvoztwu22aJ9FabdRc/DKpvLwK54I4dazCl3sHSaZFU+Rz5E+6o/MVP8snBzY02Sfry2z7l tyd5gqYLbZL0UB09rT3x0zyFLp5C6SHq5ik80dMSGsB3aXojl7Z8iW9P9Ab1uV2a3iHoeFuc 5A0M322SLD3eKcUT6yB3qRlc1wzW8cQv5K8P4+HwNJcuVYSrKhJ3MxdKl+GfcOlUV3hdV1jL 6Yl1hbvVFV7XlY63k+rKO7iv0CbJYqTt4iREBC1+WqAUZeNSlIqmi9I3HYpvL1Q2FX6iX4dC VTRdqB2/i9rvicXr0EDe9bn66m6A2qtsIOSk+PlOHBqHIEk3QfdqysZBTgqiQsntatYNw2s5 rK/miU1ECjpdzbqJdPwuar8nXs3ILb9Rld/I9BvV+ZWfTvAau3mNtVdqljKX3yqvgcJPyS24 VtomyUrEOpVJjmc4PS00ULfQQOvQwE2HdWigp4YG6hYaaB0aOn4Xtd/TKhO4CNsmqdBAOsUr QwM9LTRQl9BAVWgIu1dThgZ6WmigbqGB1qGBtBzWV/PU0EDdQgOtQ0PH76L2e+LVdAsNtA4N sem3Dg30tNBA3UIDrUODkVtO69BATw0NzC23rM5tYo5nq9wGCj/FL3fzy2u/l+bYqPbLT/Mb yogOnfHp0pTfoAn8oQz8N9JvyNWnE7zGbl5j7ZUGTeAPZeDXXgOFn5Jb6pZbWuc2NnJL69zS 03JL3XJL69wSI7e0zi09NbfMLbeszm1i+GVVbgOFn+KXu/nltd9Lwy+v/fLT/M6SB4cAqVhq MYc+Pg6wg4y/jK7T4QraNypRqUVz68rbaiV51XEry+3cNoJcpr66si/ltfizZHk/ntoPqPUR tb511altdp3Yz9WBrLOeg3V2o0Xn+BvIKkvFuqjXNpK3nNxM7mYuBXPE1V6se64WS20qj9GJ euXi6shA3b0dWpfI2+afVreTn+/GLpnqUnWerJusLcPFcj6603cb4pfdQtZ+ei7+ajKejW9W WMWy0cqd9bGME+Ain8UcLi0bTXthVHoBF4xWd5fKfjyaXiZ3ned9dEGlaC2S5v0CyXA4Xq06 512OYRFn/Ni3HlEzyPIRGp2TZEeout/NX1trnUGeQipT3c5xgQmoMDlz1ZCPNAFlJKiEaFZY n1RhkMvnZUBaJTzo/MhThhGWyLvlGC4tBao0FtZTbA31cjmf/3S7HI8BqRpX4/u4sPZeDV0/ 3gDQ0mAnp8BRmz8p6SSoHhAACSqwdSmurMc8DBN1/z6kp0A1fH500qG9QlTn0HrqyeCWN+tD UiWsV5GsQbohq7voASGFqbbAfCRJ+pZyQEeDZqGjySpvqYYENWoI0lDt2yCiK6ieCcRMHuXW 45ENv74LFdCrcXWTuY/UjMkI0hGInvCPEAV1Qw0kokBVs8ICKyN9fwqgpEGVohzpgdTtHICM wixR0btECupUUSfN+UP7qQttSNX+GAk55clFIGUlqhuS/SavhtyZcJiAEiCP1gO2DW/FAIEV 65QNZ/YH7Rkm11B3KxDd22ZIR7YCFXR/LcI5pvATpPCTLhHfejbL4M1vPkESAtJbGEiDl48w mU6aYcOZHdYDB0ysPAsBpKlEdfHabztuyHoaCihpsNMg1GqaGIwKqnoF2H739FTsB78LL7v9 YGKu9fzdD+T8xj/9z3+vXpb813ygz3+nXL//gVK5Qamf/xp8f/7rt/gBRlOfhlMxhj/+MhmN oeHEdDWp7jT8uzP1/cf5p6/9m+9S/ys+sPbvhX77+c/UE5+/t/9v8dNeil18nEwni1W6SpI4 ZN55Z/mXpavxTLR5FnqL0fB7M/9/8NP7/Hf51r8P9Ef/x+DDlkXBB/kCwM36ZB/97d9nhAed 9k+Y531v/9/iR77KWk8G8kF5snog39j59PXl/bwEY0+edpLPbZBgts3lBwn61fxa38k02L5+ 4ZwGxxBvoI32R8K4vPd28LY7fNmtd0UX27Qw9WhCfVZHPV9LcMlAvljx6Wm7ezFxwvTzFskg P/gBebdhrAfjx5g8b6keo0wHLwfOIxPKVXKoKrjDa5Fvs6ftO0gwEeoVA/2QUAnlX/OnbFMc 7ASCEShGYBjBxwi8n0CxXFAoF3wz0M91OypdFsXVo5hFzXt9fdrmu2crThGc2XC5GlDehdV1 HXlRoM9qeoOtfMjU/uXzESofLaTQD2/5zoZGfba015b22vq9tqIxW9BCXgh5HWJRmPJ1K2XV E/8URD2lNCvk2bD89V/Zfp99PcbXnjxCkOdiYGgBiXwOYAckqtpXV5CzPPzf6P0dwl/yvaD0 EA5fn3sIFPFAMQ8MEWCYgI8I+JhA4EDoL4Q1prDGFHJMIccUNpjCBlN4xBQeEQV7RW7wqN8D 6a8r8lRjj3sKVVVSlI+wFLTn4nO2z7abYzxWqe/DIXtKdepk+pJZ+TICA2dBWXwCf9zs5FuP TDgMy7sLBPyvp93nrWjMr8cEqjosTXjMLTgFcLUOV/n/vHn7YsVID7YBMQJrqjMqHYj5WeNu 8/wuH6hsFGU15hFZitSYJ3x/f093TxYKJSiFyUfA9FM47ohzlBJ4DKeEHKegKnimQ1wldFCh OIXhFB+nyMe39FMiPEcRnqMIz1GE5yjCcxTh9SUKcEqIU6I+Cm8CMkYhOIXhlEeUwvG0cDwt HHcU4Y4i3FGEZzrC05LjacnxtOR4WnJbWsigmbvpoZh6SWi+PYb11M4C694t9OU4rA+ONbx5 zvrgjjXT3Yi6I/KwFZMBwmyw3wsHtB/uFw97YfEt6YftxVLBcb91HPbBgWdPmk91Lylhi28T 3v+hNgdsqP1ymzBkzNRYxWasKmMu5nR9cEAB1wre8MBuzRUcy7mhFdZDi40D/LrJxWitGiSa uN9v7uPm9upgwr3mQNYN2GYeeM2KhcVcw0HIsh44igI7HEbNaocFjjx9UWN7zmMdnwLfXq41 zKzhowtD1kE/bC/VGrbHpmxT5pv3wTwQ8OEporkgmvhatWH5jkERmJ+2z4S/s2OcU2IPnBVM rYlTK0teOTt2gN+y18KK+3bzoMybtT7VcNgPR+Lf37eZKJr3VnWtCTFCCBAF5snDWD2EiDIC EALtQk2adoe1b8OIPX8xKQtPDl0LEc7ayiaMWNsuTY0H/erWKt/AYb91aLPeFAoWAcZW6dRC l7RWE2kQJpQWKPy63b7bMGv0bcN2U+pbL1Ybhkyt/VEbhkx9W8xsw6Dput90DZmGalgPmmoY MCW9xaRhyDTuqxUaBkwDa8fUhu2mkZ/3lbCG26axT9QoJVCh2TClzcqpXHVldPD2lL3YEB9E OISI/g1CmB1Zy6mXFZEPT4QQBvh5JDDCuwjRi9NqJ+hr8fS0+/fj1gpTAFavQ5OjwJfs7VA8 b02QVO/0Grz99rR9tUExCBEfhuxWOiWyE/7t5ctzcWRIskGWFy/bvIVkVQz+8kr0ELeC1GOl 1MbRa/5SvDFqAwkADvR7P0Xs/fz6Odu/mbA51+mB/V5YzXV64H7xuJxQxO0sa1RUhsCK5vof 77isKogcQ756cWAsJtpHF01BNAwtl1o9ucqLRBn8e/uy3r1sPojPx4RYEF4K+mu7ZZcoz8Rw 2YYGa11XiKwqn4tnE4s2uo51212DdFtxg3SjhUCKZhJ1XC0juUFLZLCypENidC0Gl8dYFlet 57hCr0ONEQt2KTGfi79YzuP3I4jLqRUIhRBEYIjCUAwnI6YwxHsgAkMUhEJQcA0mPoALSkAB BIl5PAxBKRSQD0ChnO/YIflKLRiCCkotKYIQlOVYBjoQSkAIvJSxB17KGC55AUUwBCaDwgUV 9UG2ZERVZ1K8bvNOHKzAwAZWc0SfWKN2Cav1kh6YITDthRHfftgLc8BahUY5kLIF4o0KZJxY RgglxCzdRiE7m0i+b8amqVEi0Iiw+G23s4As6gNtltVMlKm53lE+azi2FkM90fX64dhaxg0c 9cEB7Fv2lDSwFZdGmSfGpmJ2/GH/ZftSWGAxgIbhQC5BW2F1qIfI6bOlRCswOLrCNRQCUCwX Y48gWf17T1QODlmmTlYaRr5slj4Tfx1+jaOn1vCW+Fe6zbLB5vP+YCJBtZVrvyQ1HFthfbhF joxF577JXvLiGJVJspSaev+NdVCtoVw+eecIWnvdoukcJx28PuecE9PGPDm13+6OocgGPara Jh/I1x0Jaoj4og3YKqJCqRyq20d85CpQgdcykKTyPEI56hns97+9vBR7E9avWPTFX0eWEdW9 VDzYPD8Wx4is2jACyMkVUsjo+LpVEDs2yooqW0eDuRqjFixnChP9oaWkNcplNLGgjKgBpG28 XkPHFUxDxA6pji8WF/ZL9pzlX1re1EtG5NP8j3NRYsyKjeSMLrm0FGcNsWPoSk0aqB5wd9sd L0mBrd1xouq1HBE8FtnTy7sNYzAmYnMXYxu2aZbwPmfPet33CIyOQN9TB+fsSfUzIo9/yhcN W65veUjNk1O9TvFUZ+5kx1oUr/tdq/nWqAijAKqDsG3eacC2MUilTb0+zxROl4Qz6+CoOZTX Z0ztc/FmScs62TZg0LWGwUxrmPXDfj9sG5A0cNSf8rgfzqxwQWXsYfYapuYQot3Goh+Sp7sf t/uylanVG70UJUZC0eDt+VBb6r0Ool9uIyKGmEcf3vZF9lxF8haBFYPd09fn1yomlDslQR0R 118PhxYkwxNjIrfHTjcZmKBydCAzZmLlPfPlGtbVYFM8vr8bUGnmqUHFY9nEVItVt0NXrXr7 +iU7FCa6DpoN2y+7/faP3YsVltXteZ0dDtlmt7cyKMAg1YKXaMUvWxtAj4BN07mKKCyvqQnT sBwYy0Ntu32RitIyM0Vi1tj/8X/tnUty4yoUhud3FdrArRLoPex07+AuwIVATtyRbJclu+Os /nIARUiCQwY95J8k5e+AeB/Ew2bTsGJfDg6aia5xF8+2vE7tOmiSfuDW5yRVK0vKD4+c5zZ6 Sed8jqJn4vb4x6R+LjdZcxx2oNn0lL752Dp5iXG4f4/zgqKc4s+XHI+fwp4Byrmbz8uosB04 vbINNBUJgwLvX7uzB+c4rnHMUdzioVs8tMBTLvCUi9KJ6Yt+O4P924FNt8vHsT20pmfvjH58 x6j9jtHxG0bgt8JG5DtGRdBIj1thI/RxXJd1BzX1drqO67LW92QyAduW14GuYcf0UkQN5xO2 jVdD/TbDn213g3/dJiRkUiCxUDKfbJWtZhLHDw8tUNrsqTUj3Gfegs0OqnsW4Ldr6N7/ZZN8 ZbO5tSMrHFWTm7yrsTgr0qSdpocDEA8oOx84boF6hYd5B4xvcrRn4jTaWCjvWcJadNLePx1I zdQ+Lze9DJ878ueF8MX1S3rI3PWt20zayW9ZhrAcYeqmE62JzWi2tFJZTaI7T05MnNhs7ihX PJ5M11nDAoMlBuEXiZCnVu6wlXW+5DkczRRqRxlKOUoFRqEvI5S6qH1gx5FfcyAnL9yVoHFF PHXE60T/mGByHmhRHthd6AWUrUHpMxB6TiQb+u30YOvinlmNsAZhPxH2y89++NMCyyR+RhCW +RlB4iRInASJs0DiLJA4C0ec+sainkwPd5K+kw2EKm7gEF83kqxaU73iWtTLcaVdG4A7e3Ph ygEbJsYOTBo4QBnAMMZe/sWMGkjlOF76C3HxCn9GhT2j0rc8Mjg/tisJQ7WzVTR10LpOXWGF rgDi6AjZsVwKjw/rzr9AgkCCQrqD6oXAzH3mwvg4qf8sI+Om1X3IZLzId63Hqe3GxcI6xAQH WmqSbluGdVYpaJEHLeqARUWanUU1D4OweKf2+K7sdr3cpsOVW9zsSsDBPifP5PRWOUtP+C9O ApzinAbip4H4szzAiwBH808D+aeB/NNA/mkg/zSQfyobRICHwgfSVwbiLwPxl57487RKzA4G zkPhM5TX/vgb1YHkEIxx6uUCzrBQ4qu/olEDYFV70v/F9+k3S1hm6ytPuitnLlJ4SeklzZZk XC/HyHY+Ps+8P53fgdbagZaVOplNwDj5U5YNtaD6EWj4UUUm/74d+cEMuTtMcSz9SPs+HFg+ OXFtcL3Q+UAZbIvqxaX581xPLFW6d8+UuF7ek7t+ZHuWOVmhz+3L/O+Kgai7UrM7czyz1UUI 6/bJK/vsegeECQ4CqReqAd5RPh3MjXIYXaarXrEzhGgf16mVKCFds5PlCCv2LDfbf5WzBBbs aicWdrUTC2dObL937prRGk9d343r4NILq24o664lewRMzQbYYzi4QhK1NL0NWZqLxHCMT84i +NOCWfnlmN+eozjbqNH3h1vhLEeD29Td0BZc4rjCcY3jBscMxy2OOYY9HQz2G6HUXn45m1fR pkihwndhJ/qr95M/YlrDTo7S1tL778OIsLuTySY9dqJv2b27xW+MioqKioqKioqKioqKioqK ioqKioqKioqKioqKioqKioqKioqK+mv6H60dnkkAGAEA

--WIyZ46R2i8wDzkSu-- - To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/