Re: [PATCH] 2.5.44-ac3, cciss, more scatter gather elements

[Jens Axboe]

On Fri, Oct 25 2002, Stephen Cameron wrote:
> 
> Add blk_rq_map_sg_one_by_one function to ll_rw_blk.c in order to allow a low 
> level driver to map scatter gather elements from the block subsystem one 
> at a time into device specific data structures instead of having to take 
> a copy of all of them all at once and then afterwards copy them into a device 
> specific format. 
> 
> To follow, a patch to the cciss driver using this interface which
> allows up to 256 scatter gather elements (current limit is 31). 

I have to say that I think this patch is ugly, and a complete duplicate
of existing code. This is always bad, especially in the case of
something not really straight forward (like blk_rq_map_sg()). A hack.

I can understand the need for something like this, for drivers that
can't use a struct scatterlist directly. I'd rather do this in a
different way, though.

__blk_rq_map(q, rq, sglist, callback)
{
	...
	/* do the mapping *.
	if (sglist) {
		sglist[nsegs].page = bvec->bv_page;
		...
	} else
		callback(q, bvec, nsegs);
}

blk_rq_map_rq(q, rq, sglist)
{
	return __blk_rq_map(q, rq, sglist, NULL);
}

blk_rq_map_callback(q, rq, callback)
{
	return __blk_rq_map(q, rq, NULL, callback);
}

Or use a cookie like you currently do.

Oh, and do try to follow the style. It's

	if (cond)
		foo();

not

	if (fond) foo();

-- 
Jens Axboe